How Have His Predecessors Fared With This Dilemma?
After a disastrous 2025 Champions Trophy marketing campaign, wherein England misplaced all three video games to complete backside of their group, coupled with an equally poor 2023 World Cup, it led to Jos Buttler’s resignation as England’s white-ball captain.
With a lot deliberation, the ECB determined to nominate Harry Brook because the captain of the England ODI and T20I sides.
The 26-year-old had beforehand captained the England ODI facet throughout the 2023 ODI sequence at house with Australia, the place the guests prevailed 3-2. Nevertheless, Brook was the main run-scorer within the sequence with 312 runs, together with a match-winning 110* within the third ODI.
His maiden ODI hundred was the standout second in an in any other case up-and-down ODI profession that has struggled as of late.
Will probably be primarily within the ODI format the place the Yorkshireman must rediscover the shape that made England nearly unbeatable as they broke a number of data within the course of.
Some, reminiscent of ESPNcricinfo’s Andrew Miller, have questioned whether or not captaincy will likely be a burden on the younger famous person in an ever-growing cricket calendar.
Whereas others, reminiscent of Sky Sports activities’ Michael Atherton, have highlighted the dearth of choices accessible and supported the choice to make Brook the thirty seventh ODI and twelfth T20I captain for England.
World In Sport has regarded into the impact on the person efficiency of England gamers of their careers and after being appointed captain. We now have assessed the three gamers who’ve achieved the best variety of England ODI video games as captain.
Eoin Morgan
ODI Captain Document: Performed: 126, Received: 76, Tied: 2, Loss: 40, No Outcome: 8
2011-2022 Wpercent60.32
ODI Profession Stats: Performed 248, Runs: 7701, Common: 39.29
ODI Stats as Captain: Performed: 126, Runs: 4403, Common: 44.03
Morgan acquired the captaincy in interim spells from 2011 however was handed the reins completely earlier than the 2015 Cricket World Cup. Though that event ended abysmally, he oversaw the transformation of English cricket that led to England’s maiden Cricket World Cup victory in 2019.
Harry Brook will likely be looking for to comply with Morgan’s achievements as captain and with the bat. Not solely is Morgan England’s main run-scorer in restricted overs cricket, however no England captain within the fashionable period has the next win share than Morgan in ODI cricket, with 60.32%.
No England participant has scored greater than 4 ODI tons of as captain (he has 8), epitomised as Morgan’s common as captain rose to 44.03 from a profession common of 39.29, exhibiting captaincy improved Morgan and England’s document.
Alastair Prepare dinner
ODI Captain Document: Performed: 69, Received: 36, Tied: 1, Loss: 30, No Outcome: 2
2010-2014 Wpercent52.17
ODI Profession Stats: Performed: 92, Runs: 3204, Common: 36.41
ODI Stats as Captain: Performed: 69, Runs: 2502, Common: 38.49
The previous Essex man led England’s ODI staff completely from 2011 till his elimination from the position earlier than the 2015 World Cup..The spotlight of his tenure was the runner-up place achieved throughout the 2013 Champions Trophy, the place England misplaced to India.
Brook will likely be seeking to emulate Prepare dinner’s type with the captaincy. Though Prepare dinner’s common rose solely marginally from a profession 36.41 to 38.49 as captain, between 2010 and 2013, he averaged 45.13 with 4 tons of and fifteen fifties in 69 innings.
Throughout this time, Prepare dinner captained England in 69 video games, successful 36 (52.2% win charge). Of ODI gamers to captain England greater than 30 occasions, solely Mike Gatting (70.28%), Michael Vaughan (53.33%), and Eoin Morgan (60.3%) have the next win-rate.
Andrew Strauss
ODI Captain Document: Performed: 62, Received: 27, Tied: 1, Loss: 33, No Outcome: 1
2006-2011 Wpercent43.55
ODI Profession Stats: Performed: 125, Runs 4205, Common: 35.64
ODI Stats as Captain: Performed: 62, Runs: 2367, Common: 39.45
A masterful captain for England’s check facet, Strauss’s experience didn’t stretch to the one-day facet. A semi-final exit on the 2009 Champions Trophy, adopted by a quarter-final departure on the 2011 World Cu,p had been notable moments from an underwhelming captaincy that meant England misplaced half of their video games underneath his management (43.55% win charge).
With the bat that the previous Middlesex man proved his resilience. His common as captain jumped considerably from a profession 35.64 to 39.45, and he scored nearly all of his ODI tons of as captain (4), together with a masterful 158 towards India on the 2011 World Cup.
Brook can have learnt a lesson from Strauss on the significance of sustaining a successful staff, one thing that finally led to his downfall as white-ball captain.
